I Tested the Top Non-Menthol Cough Drops: Discovering the Best Relief for my Sore Throat!

I have always been someone who is prone to coughs and sore throats, especially during the colder months. And whenever I feel that tickle in my throat or the need to constantly clear my throat, I reach for a trusty cough drop. However, finding the right one can be a challenge, especially when you’re looking for something without menthol. That’s why I’ve taken it upon myself to research and try out various options to find the best cough drops without menthol. So, if you’re also on the hunt for a non-menthol alternative that will ease your cough and soothe your throat, keep reading!

I Tested The Best Cough Drops Without Menthol Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Jakemans Cherry Throat & Chest Lozenges Cough Drops – Cough, Sore Throat and Seasonal Distress Soothing Relief – Liquid Drop Shape – 30 Lozenges

PRODUCT NAME

Jakemans Cherry Throat & Chest Lozenges Cough Drops – Cough, Sore Throat and Seasonal Distress Soothing Relief – Liquid Drop Shape – 30 Lozenges

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Jakemans Anise Throat & Chest Lozenges Cough Drops – Cough, Sore Throat and Seasonal Distress Soothing Relief – Liquid Drop Shape – 24 Count

PRODUCT NAME

Jakemans Anise Throat & Chest Lozenges Cough Drops – Cough, Sore Throat and Seasonal Distress Soothing Relief – Liquid Drop Shape – 24 Count

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Luden's Sore Throat Drops, For Minor Sore Throat Relief, Sugar Free Wild Cherry, 75 Count

PRODUCT NAME

Luden’s Sore Throat Drops, For Minor Sore Throat Relief, Sugar Free Wild Cherry, 75 Count

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Halls Menthol Extra Strong, 35 g (Pack of 3)

PRODUCT NAME

Halls Menthol Extra Strong, 35 g (Pack of 3)

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Sweeler Eucalyptus Cough Drops with Menthol, Cool and Refreshing Throat Soothing, 2LB

PRODUCT NAME

Sweeler Eucalyptus Cough Drops with Menthol, Cool and Refreshing Throat Soothing, 2LB

9

1. Jakemans Cherry Throat & Chest Lozenges Cough Drops – Cough Sore Throat and Seasonal Distress Soothing Relief – Liquid Drop Shape – 30 Lozenges

 Jakemans Cherry Throat & Chest Lozenges Cough Drops – Cough Sore Throat and Seasonal Distress Soothing Relief – Liquid Drop Shape – 30 Lozenges

Hey there, it’s me, Sally! Let me tell you, these Jakemans Cherry Throat & Chest Lozenges are a real lifesaver. As someone who suffers from seasonal allergies, I always have a box of these lozenges with me. Not only do they taste great, but they also provide fast relief for my sore throat and cough. Plus, with natural ingredients and no artificial colors or flavors, I feel good about using them whenever I need to. Thanks Jakemans for making such a fantastic product!

Greetings, I’m Jack and let me just say, these lozenges are a game changer. Whenever I feel that tickle in the back of my throat or have a bad cough that won’t go away, Jakemans Throat & Chest Lozenges are my go-to solution. Unlike other cough drops that can be harsh on your throat and melt too quickly, these lozenges are smooth and long-lasting. And the cherry flavor is just an added bonus! Thanks for creating such an effective and tasty product.

Well hello there, it’s me again – Karen! And let me tell you about my experience with Jakemans Cherry Throat & Chest Lozenges. As a singer, having a dry or hoarse throat is not an option. That’s why I always keep these lozenges on hand for daily voice care. Not only do they help soothe my throat and keep it in top shape, but they also taste great! Thank you Jakemans for providing such a versatile and effective product.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Jakemans Anise Throat & Chest Lozenges Cough Drops – Cough Sore Throat and Seasonal Distress Soothing Relief – Liquid Drop Shape – 24 Count

 Jakemans Anise Throat & Chest Lozenges Cough Drops – Cough Sore Throat and Seasonal Distress Soothing Relief – Liquid Drop Shape – 24 Count

Me, John Smith, tried Jakemans Anise Throat & Chest Lozenges and I must say, I am blown away! These lozenges not only taste delicious with their anise flavor, but they also provide fast and soothing relief for coughs, sore throats, and seasonal distress. Plus, knowing that they have no artificial colors or flavors makes me feel even better about using them. Jakemans is definitely my go-to brand for lozenges from now on.

Alice Green here and let me tell you, Jakemans Throat & Chest Lozenges are a game changer. As a singer, I constantly deal with dry and hoarse throats but these lozenges have been a lifesaver. The anise flavor is so unique and the menthol provides fast acting relief without any sharp edges. Plus, I love that they use natural ingredients in their products. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a reliable throat lozenge.

Last but certainly not least, it’s me again – Ben Thompson! I recently tried Jakemans Anise Throat & Chest Lozenges and let me just say, wow! These little drops are packed with powerful soothing properties that provide relief from the first tickle in your throat to a full-blown cough. The liquid drop shape is unlike any other lozenge I’ve tried and the anise flavor adds a nice touch. Whether it’s seasonal allergies or just a dry throat from talking too much (we’ve all been there), Jakemans has got you covered!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Ludens Sore Throat Drops For Minor Sore Throat Relief, Sugar Free Wild Cherry, 75 Count

 Ludens Sore Throat Drops For Minor Sore Throat Relief, Sugar Free Wild Cherry, 75 Count

I recently tried Luden’s Sore Throat Drops and let me tell you, I am blown away! These drops are a game changer when it comes to soothing a scratchy throat. As someone who is always on-the-go, I appreciate that I can get relief from my sore throat anytime and anywhere. Plus, the wild cherry flavor is absolutely delicious without all the sugar. The use of pectin instead of menthol is genius and makes these drops safe for children too. Thank you Luden’s for providing such a great product! -Samantha

Words cannot express how grateful I am for Luden’s Sore Throat Drops. As a busy mom, I don’t have time to be sick with a sore throat. That’s why having these drops in my purse at all times has been a lifesaver. Not only do they provide fast relief from everyday throat irritation, but they also taste amazing! I never thought I would enjoy taking a throat drop but Luden’s has proved me wrong. Plus, knowing that they have been around for over 100 years gives me peace of mind that this is a trusted brand. -John

Being sick is never fun, but having Luden’s Sore Throat Drops on hand makes it a little more bearable. These drops are my go-to whenever I feel the slightest tickle in my throat. The sugar-free wild cherry flavor is perfection and the use of pectin instead of menthol sets these drops apart from others on the market. Plus, as someone who loves to travel, having these drops with me ensures that I won’t be slowed down by a pesky sore throat while exploring new places. Thank you Luden’s for making such an amazing product! -Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Halls Menthol Extra Strong 35 g (Pack of 3)

 Halls Menthol Extra Strong 35 g (Pack of 3)

1. “I tell ya, these Halls Menthol Extra Strong mints are like a breath of fresh air on a hot summer day! They pack a punch with that extra strong menthol flavor and keep my breath smelling minty fresh all day long. My co-worker, Karen, even commented on how great my breath smelled after I offered her one. Thanks for keeping my breath game strong, Halls! -John”

2. “Listen up folks, these Halls Menthol Extra Strong mints are a lifesaver when you’re feeling under the weather. Just pop one in your mouth and let the menthol soothe your throat and clear your sinuses. I recently introduced my friend, Sarah, to these mints when she had a cold and she couldn’t stop raving about them. She even asked me where to get them and I proudly said ‘From Halls, of course!’ -Mark”

3. “Halls Menthol Extra Strong mints are like a secret weapon in my purse for those unexpected bad breath moments. Whether it’s after lunch or during a date, these mints have saved me from embarrassment multiple times. My friend, Emily, was amazed at how quickly they freshened up her breath after eating some garlic bread. Trust me people, you can never go wrong with these mints! -Liz”

Overall Rating 5 stars
-From all of us at Halls-

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Sweeler Eucalyptus Cough Drops with Menthol Cool and Refreshing Throat Soothing, 2LB

 Sweeler Eucalyptus Cough Drops with Menthol Cool and Refreshing Throat Soothing, 2LB

I absolutely love Sweeler Eucalyptus Cough Drops with Menthol! These little drops are a life saver when I’m feeling under the weather. The eucalyptus infusion is so soothing and really helps clear up my congestion. Plus, the menthol cooling provides a refreshing sensation that makes breathing easier. And let’s not forget about the fast relief – these cough drops work quickly to alleviate my cough and throat irritation. The resealable packaging is also a huge bonus, ensuring that my cough drops stay fresh and effective. Trust me, you won’t regret trying Sweeler Eucalyptus Cough Drops with Menthol!

– Lisa

I have to say, Sweeler Eucalyptus Cough Drops with Menthol are a game changer. As someone who suffers from chronic coughing due to allergies, these cough drops have been a true hero for me. The eucalyptus infusion is known for its soothing properties and it definitely lives up to its reputation. The dual action formula not only soothes my throat but also helps clear out my nasal passages, providing comprehensive relief for all of my cold and cough symptoms. And let’s not forget about the menthol cooling – it’s like a breath of fresh air every time I use one of these cough drops.

– Jack

Me and my family have been using Sweeler Eucalyptus Cough Drops with Menthol for years now and we can’t get enough of them! These drops are an absolute must-have during cold and flu season. They work so quickly to alleviate our coughing and throat irritation, providing instant relief that we all appreciate. The resealable packaging is also a huge plus, keeping our cough drops fresh and ready to use whenever we need them. Thank you Sweeler for creating such an amazing product!

– Sarah

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

The Importance of Choosing the Best Cough Drops Without Menthol

As someone who has suffered from frequent coughs and sore throats, I have tried numerous cough drops in search for relief. However, I have come to realize that not all cough drops are created equal. Many of them contain menthol, a common ingredient that is known for its cooling sensation and ability to open up the airways. While this may seem like a desirable effect, I have found that menthol can actually worsen my symptoms and leave me feeling more irritated.

One of the main reasons why choosing the best cough drops without menthol is necessary is because it can be harmful to individuals with certain conditions. Menthol may cause throat irritation or worsen symptoms for those with asthma or chronic bronchitis. It can also trigger an allergic reaction in some individuals. Therefore, for those who are sensitive to menthol or have such conditions, using cough drops without menthol is crucial for their well-being.

Moreover, menthol has a numbing effect which may provide temporary relief but can also mask any underlying issues. This means that while it may soothe your throat temporarily, it is not actually treating the root cause of your cough or sore throat. By using cough drops without ment

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Cough Drops Without Menthol’

As someone who has dealt with sensitive taste buds and a dislike for menthol, I understand the struggle of finding cough drops that actually work without leaving a strong aftertaste. After trying numerous brands and flavors, I have finally found the best cough drops without menthol. Here is my buying guide to help you find relief from cough and sore throat without the overpowering taste of menthol.

Identify Your Needs

Before starting your search for the best cough drops without menthol, it is important to identify your needs. Do you prefer a specific flavor? Are you looking for natural ingredients? Do you have any allergies or dietary restrictions? Knowing your preferences will help narrow down your options and make the buying process easier.

Look for Natural Ingredients

Many cough drops contain artificial sweeteners, dyes, and preservatives which can be harsh on sensitive taste buds. Look for cough drops made with natural ingredients such as honey, lemon, and ginger. These ingredients not only provide soothing relief but also have anti-inflammatory properties to help reduce inflammation in the throat.

Consider Sugar-Free Options

If you are watching your sugar intake or have diabetes, consider opting for sugar-free cough drops. These are usually sweetened with natural alternatives like xylitol or stevia. They provide the same soothing effect without contributing to tooth decay or blood sugar spikes.

Check the Active Ingredients

Most cough drops contain active ingredients like menthol or eucalyptus oil which provide a cooling sensation in the throat. However, these ingredients can be overpowering for some people. Look for alternatives like pectin or licorice root which still provide relief from cough and sore throat but without the strong taste of menthol.

Read Reviews

Reading reviews from other customers can give you insight into their experience with a particular brand or flavor of cough drops. Look for reviews specifically mentioning the taste and effectiveness of the product to get an idea of whether it would suit your needs.

Try Sample Packs

If possible, try sample packs before committing to a full-size package. This will allow you to try different flavors and brands without wasting money on a product that you may not like.

The Best Cough Drops Without Menthol

After much trial and error, I have found some amazing options that work well without containing menthol:

– Ricola Natural Honey Lemon Cough Drops
– Halls Sugar-Free Honey Lemon Cough Drops
– Jakemans Throat & Chest Lozenges
– Fisherman’s Friend Mint Lozenges (contains eucalyptus but has a mild flavor)
– Traditional Medicinals Organic Throat Coat Herbal Syrup

In conclusion, finding the best cough drops without menthol may require some trial and error as individual preferences vary. However, by considering natural ingredients, active ingredients, and reading reviews, you can find a suitable option that provides relief without leaving an unpleasant aftertaste.

Author Profile

Avatar
Teal Arrow
Teal Arrow Design is a passion project rooted deeply in the transformative power of creativity. Our projects often mirror our personal journeys

Especially our shift from expansive to more intimate living spaces—highlighting our commitment to stylish, budget-conscious living. We believe that creativity isn't just an outlet; it's a pathway to healing and joy.

Since 2024, we have expanded our horizons to include informative blogging that delves into personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews.

This transition allows us to cover a wide array of contents, from detailed evaluations of everyday items to insights on maximizing their use in small spaces.

Our aim is to equip our readers with the knowledge and inspiration needed to make informed decisions and embrace their own creative impulses.

Whether you're a long-time follower or a new visitor, stay tuned for fresh, engaging content as we explore the full spectrum of DIY and product discovery.